Skip to main content

Rental Options

Rent Now

Rent

Reservation

Reserve
Filter Results View Map

Self Storage Units near Shelter Island,

Find your closest Life Storage to get started!

  • 1 Month Free on select units
  • Book online, save up to 25%
  • Reserve for free - no obligation
  • Rent Now to get instant access

Sort by

Filter by: Size and Type

Filter by: Climate Controlled

Filter by: Access

Filter by: Specials

Customer Reviews - Shelter Island

We at Life Storage want to maintain the best self storage facilities in Shelter Island, and in every city where we do business. That's why we routinely ask our customers about their experience with us and challenge ourselves to make it better. You can read what customers think about us here on our website - over the past four years, we've had over 100,000 customers respond to our surveys and tell us what they think. We publish their reviews here, and we're proud of the result!

Write a Review

Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars christine moynihan at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"I rented two storage units for my boss . The store manager Ty Hook went above and beyond to accommodate me. He was polite , professional and fortunately had lots of patience showing me many units . I would highly recommend using Life Storage in East Hampton"

November 08, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Roma T at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"New client at the Life Storage EH. Store manager Ty Hook professional, honest and super helpful! Highly recommend, great experience overall"

October 31, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Taylor Camarena at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"Ty was a HUGE help! I flew across the country to get into my storage unit and of course, forgot my key. He was able to help me and made it such a great experience!"

October 24, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Jayleen L. at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"Renting the space was very easy. Ty, the manager, has been helpful from day 1! My sister had rented here before moving out of state, with no issues. I originally rented a 5 x 10 without humidity control. After a couple of months, I noticed mold and dampness to an unusually high degree for the amount of time my stuff had been there. I think the unit was damaged in some way. My items came from a dry, humidity controlled basement--so something was off. Ty was AMAZING. He listened to what was going on, and he helped me get a new unit. No headaches whatsoever. Also, he  worked with my schedule when it came to transferring my stuff to the other unit. I didn't want to delay; it took several phone conversations. A very patient man. Also discreet. No one needs to know how much stuff we have, right? I highly recommend this place, specifically under Ty's management."

October 08, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Jeanne H. at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"I highly recommend this storage facility because they have a fantastic manager named Ty who is polite, professional, and very helpful. I needed to move quickly, and he not only found the perfect storage unit for my needs, but he made the entire process as stress free and easy as possible. Thank you, Ty!"

September 30, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Cristina T. at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"What an easy and supported experience. I moved in on my own after hours which was simple and the unit was accessible. Ty and staff offered assistance when moving out. They helped me to navigate the movers so the job was efficiently and effortlessly completed in a shorter time. Thank you Ty and all of those who contribute to the maintenance of the storage facility and to the smooth transitions in and out of storage. ."

September 28, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Lucy Musso at Life Storage, Southampton, New York (#261)

"Wonderful Natasha and Anthony were very helpful in helping me choose the right space I needed thank you !!"

September 21, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Madison C. at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"Excellent service, we've had storage for a while now. Yesterday we had a great experience working with Ty, highly recommend to work with him!"

September 17, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars william guanga at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"LifeStorage has a great service, The manager Ty Hook was exceptional: professional, thinking about your needs, offering options, processing paperwork, showing me how things operated, but most of all you had the security of feeling that your stuff, however mundane or precious, would be safe, dry and secure here. Custodians. 100% recommended Great place"

September 08, 2022
Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars Swami Malayala at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"Place keeps getting better. Got the perfect size unit for my needs. Process was easy and service was so good that I am writing to recommend others about Life Storage facility."

June 15, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Joshua Rome at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"Ty has been super helpful!"

May 11, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Cynthia K at Life Storage, Southampton, New York (#262)

"This is an awesome business. Every person I dealt with was friendly and knowledgeable. They make the entire process of renting a unit seamless. Clean facility and easy access. Highly recommend!"

April 26, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Trish Salazar at Life Storage, Southampton, New York (#261)

"These people are pros! What a great company. My close friend highly recommended that I try getting a storage unit at Life Storage. I had the privilege of speaking with Natasha today 3 different times and I’m so grateful for her kind, friendly, informative nature. Not to mention how patient! I was sure that I would take a southampton storage unit but then later in the day realized that I needed it closer to the town I actually live in or it would be a pain for me to travel an hour to my storage unit… Natasha handled it all with grace and hooked me up with finding & reserving a storage unit right in my town… good companies are only as good as their outstanding employees. Thank you Natasha! I really appreciate your patience and taking the time to call me & check up & explain everything. Looking forward to storing my stuff with a professional, well organized team to support me."

April 19, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Stan .Wiencko at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"I had a great experiences with Life Storage Ty was able to answer all my questions and solve my problems on what size storage room I would need."

April 12, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Thuyen N. at Life Storage, Southampton, New York (#261)

"I needed a climate-controlled storage immediately yesterday in the Hamptons which with the pandemic wasn't easy. I am not as much an online person as a phone person so I called life storage in Southampton where I already have one storage space. Natasha was a lifesaver for an extremely stressful day of last minute scrambling.  She guided me on how to book online and then made the rest so logistics easier so all I could just show up after hours with the U-Haul and go right into my new storage unit where there was a welcome bag with the lock and all the instructions.  I'm grateful for Natasha's professionalism and being a calm during my storm.  She and Life Storage, Southampton we're wonderful!"

April 01, 2022
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Jean-luc C. at Life Storage, East Hampton, New York (#264)

"Can't be happier! I've been using this facility for almost 10 years and I've always been very satisfied with the service. Ty, the manager is the best, always smiley, welcoming and ready to help. He just found me a new unit, Thank you so much!!"

March 28, 2022

Frequently Asked Questions

What size storage unit do I need in Shelter Island, ?

The size will depend on how much stuff you need to store. To avoid renting too small or too large a storage unit, we recommend reading a Storage Unit Size Guide or using an interactive Storage Unit Size Estimator Tool to determine exactly how much space you'll need. Our most popular sizes in Shelter Island, NY are the 5x5, 5x10, and 10x10.

How big is a 5x5 storage unit?

A 5x5 self storage unit is 25 square feet or 200 cubic feet of storage space. It measures 5 feet wide by 5 feet long and most have an 8 foot ceiling height. A 5x5 storage unit is the size of an average closet and it should fit a dresser, a small mattress set, and several medium moving boxes. Here's our 5x5 storage unit video to learn more. In Shelter Island, our prices start at $68 for a 5x5 unit.

How big is a 5x10 storage unit?

A 5x10 self storage unit is 50 square feet or 400 cubic feet of storage space. It measures 5 feet wide by 10 feet long and typically has an 8 foot ceiling. For comparison, a 5x10 storage unit is about the size of an average walk-in closet. It fits 1 to 2 large pieces of furniture and about 10 to 15 moving boxes. Feel free to watch our 5x10 storage unit video to learn more. In Shelter Island, our prices start at $125 for a 5x10 unit.

How big is a 10x10 storage unit?

A 10x10 self storage unit is 100 square feet or 800 cubic feet of storage space. It measures 10 feet wide by 10 feet long and usually has an 8 foot ceiling. A 10x10 storage unit is about the size of an average bedroom or half of a standard one-car garage. It should fit all the contents of a family room or a two-bedroom 750 sq. ft. apartment. To learn more, here is our 10x10 storage unit video. In Shelter Island, our prices start at $219 for a 10x10 unit.

Should I rent climate controlled storage in Shelter Island?

With cold winters and occasionally hot summers in Shelter Island, we recommend climate controlled storage units to help protect your belongings over time. 6 of our stores offer climate controlled storage units near Shelter Island .

Should I rent humidity controlled storage in Shelter Island?

The humidity in Shelter Island can be extreme at times. Humidity controlled storage can help protect and preserve documents, furniture, and electronics! 4 of our stores offer humidity controlled spaces near Shelter Island .

What is the advantage of self storage with drive-up access?

If you need to frequently move items in and out of your storage space, drive-up access is the most convenient space for you. You can drive your vehicle next to the space and load or unload. 5 of our stores offer drive-up accessible storage units near Shelter Island .

How much do self storage units cost in Shelter Island?

The average cost of a 1 month self storage unit rental in Shelter Island is $306.22 with prices starting at $40.00 . The prices can vary from store to store so be sure to check nearby locations in the Shelter Island area. Storage unit sizes range from 15 sq. ft. to 360 sq. ft., and come in a variety of climate and accessibility types. Look for a great move-in offer! Our spaces often have a special discount for new customers. Spaces with a special offer will be marked with the discount you'll receive.

Self Storage Pricing in Shelter Island, New York

Climate Controlled Storage Unit Size Average Price Lowest Price
Locker $67.20 $40.00
5x5 $97.89 $68.00
5x10 $173.87 $125.00
10x10 $325.58 $219.00
10x15 $458.67 $288.00
10x20 $675.46 $316.00

Lowest storage unit pricing data is updated every 15 minutes. Average price per size represents the storage units currently available for rent at the stores in Shelter Island, NY.