Skip to main content

Rental Options

Rent Now

Rent

Reservation

Reserve
Filter Results View Map

Self Storage Units in Bay Shore,

Find your closest Life Storage to get started!

  • 1 Month Free on select units
  • Book online, save up to 25%
  • Reserve for free - no obligation
  • Rent Now to get instant access

Sort by

Filter by: Size and Type

Filter by: Climate Controlled

Filter by: Access

Filter by: Specials

Filter by: Specialty Storage

Customer Reviews - Bay Shore

We at Life Storage want to maintain the best self storage facilities in Bay Shore, and in every city where we do business. That's why we routinely ask our customers about their experience with us and challenge ourselves to make it better. You can read what customers think about us here on our website - over the past four years, we've had over 100,000 customers respond to our surveys and tell us what they think. We publish their reviews here, and we're proud of the result!

Write a Review

Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Gary Flowers at Life Storage, Deer Park, New York (#434)

"Angelina was very friendly and helped me update my information"

March 21, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars werner sencion at Life Storage, Lindenhurst, New York (#428)

"Susan was extremely helpful with explaining and setting up the whole process. The place is clean and seems secure."

March 19, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Matthew McPhillips at Life Storage, North Babylon, New York (#8705)

"Michelle is absolutely the nicest manager at any storage facility out there. She actually cares and you can tell! Thank you!"

March 16, 2023
Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars Mike R at Life Storage, North Babylon, New York (#8705)

"Samantha helped me and was truly honest and helpful. Good customer service."

March 15, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Stephanie Viela at Life Storage, Lindenhurst, New York (#428)

"Susan is amazing, friendly, and very informative. Very clean facility and in a great area. Highly recommend!"

March 11, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Faith PSN at Life Storage, North Babylon, New York (#8705)

"Samantha was very nice, respectful and helpful! made the experience a lot more enjoyable"

March 08, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars liam houlihan at Life Storage, North Babylon, New York (#8705)

"Samantha was amazing, she knew the answer to every question I had and was a great guide. She got me sold!!!!!"

March 08, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Ronald Humphrey at Life Storage, Islip, New York (#8397)

"Halima was very nice and professional made it very easy for me to choose life storage."

March 07, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Jessica T at Life Storage, Deer Park, New York (#434)

"Angelina was AMAZING to say the least! Seamless sign up online for our storage unit, and a helpful walk through by Angelina, the store manager, to show us around. She was super helpful and more people need to take note of her customer service. She answered all of my questions with no problem and made me feel comfortable with my choice with Life Storage. The storage unit itself was so clean and easy to find. The elevators work great and there is a separate entrance from the back to get into the building. Thank you Angelina… keep up the incredible work!!!"

March 07, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Jeff Calderon at Life Storage, Deer Park, New York (#434)

"Angelina, Angelina, Angelina…. You are a gem! You are the reason why we chose life storage over the competitor's extra-life storage. You were warm and welcoming and the previous comments were exactly as they described you. The CEO of life storage should personally come down and give you a seat at the big table because you single-handedly revived this company for them at this location. The comments for extra life storage showed that the customer service was rude and not helpful which swayed us to gamble at this location. And boy did it pay off. For everyone else looking for a friendly face, knowledgeable about what they sell, and peace of mind come to Life storage! Again the CEO and the boss above you should acknowledge what you have done for them and if not then you have the potential to become something BIG! Thank you for all of your help!"

March 07, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Brady Myhand at Life Storage, Deer Park, New York (#434)

"Angelina was very helpful, solved every problem I had today. I'm a new customer and I was recommended to come here by a friend. I'm so glad I did. Thank you Angelina!"

March 07, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Demetri Fields at Life Storage, Deer Park, New York (#434)

"Angelina mascot is a very nice representative and very friendly “keep her”"

March 07, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Marion Exantus at Life Storage, Deer Park, New York (#434)

"I called Deer Park and spoke to Angelina and asked if she have any spaces available. She waited for me to come. She showed me the options and gave me the information and all the rules so I understood. She showed me how to put on my lock so I know how to do it. She was very thorough and caring. I used to store in Farmingdale and Angelina used to work there and would call me when my bill is due. I’m so happy I’m storing here now and she is the manager here. She even set me up on auto pay so I won’t be late. I hope she never leaves cuz Angelina always helps me. You can tell she cares about her job."

March 06, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Quywana Ferebee at Life Storage, Deer Park, New York (#434)

"~Angelina Mascol. She gave me very great service! Very respectful and helpful with everything"

March 06, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Ellie.Mariee at Life Storage, Deer Park, New York (#434)

"Angelina Mascol- super excellent customer service, very friendly"

March 06, 2023
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars Manuel Dejesus at Life Storage, Lindenhurst, New York (#428)

"Great job explaining everything, thank you Susan and Roni"

March 04, 2023

Frequently Asked Questions

What size storage unit do I need in Bay Shore, ?

The size will depend on how much stuff you need to store. To avoid renting too small or too large a storage unit, we recommend reading a Storage Unit Size Guide or using an interactive Storage Unit Size Estimator Tool to determine exactly how much space you'll need. Our most popular sizes in Bay Shore, NY are the 5x5, 5x10, and 10x10.

How big is a 5x5 storage unit?

A 5x5 self storage unit is 25 square feet or 200 cubic feet of storage space. It measures 5 feet wide by 5 feet long and most have an 8 foot ceiling height. A 5x5 storage unit is the size of an average closet and it should fit a dresser, a small mattress set, and several medium moving boxes. Here's our 5x5 storage unit video to learn more. In Bay Shore, our prices start at $39 for a 5x5 unit.

How big is a 5x10 storage unit?

A 5x10 self storage unit is 50 square feet or 400 cubic feet of storage space. It measures 5 feet wide by 10 feet long and typically has an 8 foot ceiling. For comparison, a 5x10 storage unit is about the size of an average walk-in closet. It fits 1 to 2 large pieces of furniture and about 10 to 15 moving boxes. Feel free to watch our 5x10 storage unit video to learn more. In Bay Shore, our prices start at $69 for a 5x10 unit.

How big is a 10x10 storage unit?

A 10x10 self storage unit is 100 square feet or 800 cubic feet of storage space. It measures 10 feet wide by 10 feet long and usually has an 8 foot ceiling. A 10x10 storage unit is about the size of an average bedroom or half of a standard one-car garage. It should fit all the contents of a family room or a two-bedroom 750 sq. ft. apartment. To learn more, here is our 10x10 storage unit video. In Bay Shore, our prices start at $98 for a 10x10 unit.

Should I rent climate controlled storage in Bay Shore?

With cold winters and occasionally hot summers in Bay Shore, we recommend climate controlled storage units to help protect your belongings over time. 12 of our stores offer climate controlled storage units near Bay Shore .

What is the advantage of self storage with drive-up access?

If you need to frequently move items in and out of your storage space, drive-up access is the most convenient space for you. You can drive your vehicle next to the space and load or unload. 5 of our stores offer drive-up accessible storage units near Bay Shore .

How much do self storage units cost in Bay Shore?

The average cost of a 1 month self storage unit rental in Bay Shore is $169.49 with prices starting at $29.00 . The prices can vary from store to store so be sure to check nearby locations in the Bay Shore area. Storage unit sizes range from 12 sq. ft. to 450 sq. ft., and come in a variety of climate and accessibility types. Look for a great move-in offer! Our spaces often have a special discount for new customers. Spaces with a special offer will be marked with the discount you'll receive.

Self Storage Pricing in Bay Shore, New York

Climate Controlled Storage Unit Size Average Price Lowest Price
Locker $56.26 $29.00
5x5 $59.11 $39.00
5x10 $85.03 $69.00
10x10 $144.76 $98.00
10x15 $221.66 $178.00
10x20 $363.27 $266.00

Lowest storage unit pricing data is updated every 15 minutes. Average price per size represents the storage units currently available for rent at the stores in Bay Shore, NY.